A Tide Is Turning: The Capitol Consensus On Israel Is Crumbling


Over the previous few weeks, violence has ravaged Palestinians in Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza. The violence started with Israeli settlers, protected by the Israeli army, making an attempt to forcibly take away Palestinians within the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah from their houses. From there, it precipitated into the Israeli police attacking worshippers in Masjid Al-Aqsa, the third holiest web site in Islam, through the month of Ramadan. The violence culminated in Israel’s bombardment of Gaza, which resulted in 243 lifeless Palestinians, together with 66 youngsters.

The 11-day lengthy Israeli bombardment of Gaza was essentially the most intense since 2014, when Israel bombed Gaza for 51 days straight, ensuing within the loss of life of over 1500 civilians, together with 500 youngsters. What is strikingly totally different about 2014 and now’s {that a} tide in American civil society has turned in favor of Palestinian rights over the previous seven years. Over 50 faculty campuses have handed resolutions calling on their universities to divest from firms complicit in Israeli occupation. Multiple metropolis councils throughout the nation have divested from firms complicit in violence in opposition to Palestinians. Prominent civil society teams such because the Movement for Black Lives and Democratic Socialists of America have additionally embraced the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions Movement to strain Israel to finish its insurance policies of occupation, discrimination, and settler-colonialism. Such help has educated a large quantity of Americans on the ugly apartheid realities on the bottom. In response, politicians have had to reply to this alteration in public discourse.

In 2014, when Israel was bombing Gaza, not a single of the 535 elected officers in Congress uttered a phrase to sentence Israel’s atrocities. In reality, Senator Bernie Sanders, then the lone socialist and left-most member in both of the 2 legislative our bodies, famously defended Israel’s 2014 actions in Gaza, blaming the deaths of Palestinians on Hamas, and advised his constituents to “shut up” after they pushed again.

Help Us End Ramadan with 1000 Supporters!

Alhamdulillah, we’re at 900 supporters. Help us get to 1000 supporters earlier than Ramadan ends. All it takes is a small reward from a reader such as you to maintain us going, for simply $2 / month.

The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the perfect of deeds are those who executed persistently, even when they’re small.
Click right here to help MuslimIssues with a month-to-month donation of $2 per 30 days. Set it and gather blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you are supporting with out occupied with it.

Now, seven years later, Bernie Sanders has moved drastically additional left on Palestinian rights. He not solely acknowledges Palestinian struggling however has additionally referred to as for an finish to the lethal blockade of Gaza, for an finish to the United States “being an apologist for the Netanyahu government,” and even launched a historic decision to dam arms gross sales to Israel. Sanders is joined by practically a dozen progressives in Congress who too are crucial of Israeli actions. Much media protection has been dedicated to the truth that progressives have referred to as into query this long-held Capitol consensus that blindly stood by Israel’s actions. But what such protection has typically missed is that this leftward shift on Palestine isn’t just restricted to the progressives. It has touched each section of the Democratic Party. Senator Robert Menendez is arguably essentially the most pro-Israel Democrat in Congress, who was one in every of 4 Democrats to vote no on the Iran Deal as a consequence of strain from the Israel foyer.

In a latest assertion, Menendez acknowledged that “I am deeply troubled by Israeli military actions that resulted in the deaths of innocent civilians in Gaza as well as Israeli targeting of buildings housing international media outlets…. Israel has every right to self-defense from terrorists committed to wiping her off the face of the map. But no matter how dangerous and real that threat may be, I have always believed that the strength of the U.S. Israel relationship flourishes when it is based on the shared values of democracy, freedom, pluralism and respect for human rights and the rule of law.”

While it’s deeply problematic that his assertion ignores the imbalance of energy between the occupying Israeli state and the occupied, stateless Palestinian folks, it is very important observe that he acknowledges that Israel is killing innnocent civilians in Gaza and focusing on worldwide media retailers. This meek condemnation is one thing that not a single member of Congress may do exactly seven years in the past. It is especially noteworthy that Robert Menendez, essentially the most right-wing member of the Democratic Party on the problem, in 2021, is left of the place Bernie Sanders, essentially the most left-wing member of the Democratic Party was on the problem, in 2014. While institution Democrats have begun to acknowledge Palestinian struggling, the progressives, who beforehand struggled to do even that, have taken it a step additional.

One of crucial examples of that is the usage of the phrase apartheid to check with Israel’s actions. The apartheid cost is much from controversial. It is a cost that has been leveled on Israel by Palestinians, the South African authorities, Israeli human rights teams equivalent to B’tselem, and most just lately, by Human Rights Watch. But nonetheless, the apartheid cost has been seldom embraced by elected officers within the United States, significantly in a political local weather the place even acknowledging the struggling of Palestinians was so just lately a spot that no elected official would go. But since then, a number of members of Congress together with Cori Bush, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Rashida Tlaib, and Ayanna Pressley have charged Israel with apartheid.

Perhaps most apparently, politicians have been damage politically for blindly standing by Israel. For instance, New York City mayoral candidate, Andrew Yang, within the aftermath of such atrocities, unflinchingly stood by Israel’s actions. The subsequent day, Yang was set to look in New York City’s closely Arab neighborhood of Astoria for a meals distribution drive, just some days earlier than the Muslim vacation of Eid. Organizers then requested Yang to not come to the occasion, because of his feedback. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez tweeted that it was  “Utterly shameful for Yang to try to show up to an Eid event after sending out a chest-thumping statement of support for a strike killing 9 children, especially after his silence as Al-Aqsa was attacked”

Yang was nonetheless in Astoria the subsequent day, and was confronted by voters who advised Yang they’d not vote for him because of his remarks. Yang nonetheless stood by his tweet and refused to sentence Israel’s actions in Gaza. When polls got here out a number of days later, Andrew Yang had fallen from first to 3rd place in Democratic candidates for mayor, from 32% of ballot respondents supporting him to only 15%. Yang’s help base fell in half after he affirmed what was beforehand simply the Capitol consensus that any elected official would utter. Andrew Yang’s electoral decline could also be one of many first instances in American politics {that a} politician has been damage electorally for not supporting the human rights of Palestinians. But with the best way that the tide is popping, Yang will probably not be the final.

Recent polling has discovered that it’s not simply progressive voters, however Democratic voters as a complete, who’re clamoring for justice in Palestine. A Gallup ballot discovered that 53% of Democrats at this time favor placing strain on Israel, which is up 10% from simply three years in the past. In addition, polling has proven that two-thirds of Democrats(and 60% of Americans total) really feel as if their elected officers are extra pro-Israel than they’re. 81% of Democrats contemplate it “acceptable” and even the “duty” of members of Congress to query the US-Israel relationship. 78% of Democrats additionally favor one secular democratic state in Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza over a Jewish state that doesn’t grant equality to all of its residents.

Even liberal political pundits have joined on this shift. Peter Beinart, who notoriously supported the Iraq War, was beforehand ardent in his help for a two-state resolution even advocating what was termed “Zionist BDS” wherein Israeli settlements had been boycotted, however not the Israeli state as a complete. Earlier this 12 months, Beinart got here out in help of a one-state resolution saying {that a} two-state resolution is not possible. Eric Alterman, a fervent defender of the state of Israel affirmed that “Yes, Israel is clearly an apartheid state.’

MSNBC pundit, Ali Velshi, acknowledged that Israel’s remedy of Palestinians constitutes apartheid. He confronted a lot criticism in response to this. MSNBC pundit, Joy Reid, got here to Velshi’s protection asserting that “What @AliVelshi says in this succinct explanation is just facts: painful, well known and documented facts. Israel has a right to exist in peace but so do Palestinians, who currently suffer under what can only be called apartheid. And no one is doing anything about it.”

It is crucial to notice right here that Reid is much from a progressive. She has made Islamophobic feedback prior to now, and likewise got here underneath hearth for being unfair to the Bernie Sanders marketing campaign in 2020. Yet, even she has shifted in favor of acknowledging the rights of Palestinians.

The centrist, liberal Zionist group J Street, too, has shifted in its stances. J Street famously stood by Israel’s “right to defend itself” in Gaza in 2014 and favored elevated army support to Israel within the midst of that bombing. Since then, J Street has referred to as on Israeli airstrikes on civilians in Gaza to cease, a lifting of the blockade, and supported conditioning support to Israel on the premise of compliance with human rights. While a few of J Street’s latest statements nonetheless ignore the imbalance of energy between occupier and occupied, J Street additionally put its help behind Betty McCollum’s invoice, endorsed by 13 different members of Congress, that situations support to Israel, stating that “U.S. assistance intended for Israel’s security must never be used to violate the human rights of Palestinian children, demolish the homes of Palestinian families, or to permanently annex Palestinian lands.” In addition, J Street has moved away from the framework of a two-state resolution and is transferring in direction of a confederation mannequin, which many see as a step in direction of the final word embrace of 1 secular, non-religious, binational state for Israelis and Palestinians to stay as equal residents underneath one authorities.

The actuality is that there’s a tide delivering American public opinion. Politicians are being compelled to reply to that shift. As a outcome, the Capitol consensus in help of Israeli atrocities is crumbling. Acknowledging the humanity of Palestinians and the apartheid actuality that they stay underneath is turning into mainstream discourse. While the progressives are main the best way in turning this tide, even liberal centrist voters, politicians, organizations, and media personalities are following course. As recognition of this apartheid actuality turns into extra embraced by a bigger multitude of Americans, so too will the motion to deliver an finish to it. It is vital to notice the vital instrument that was used to finish apartheid in South Africa, and is getting used to finish apartheid in Israel at this time: Boycott, divestment, and sanctions. This tide will finally flip in order that embrace of the BDS motion to finish Israeli apartheid can be mainstream amongst Americans. When that occurs, Israel, the most important recipient of US army support, will face immense strain to finish its occupation and apartheid insurance policies, and finally transfer in direction of a day of freedom, dignity, and self-determination for Palestinians.

This article was initially printed on hamzahraza.substack.com. Visit to obtain weekly studies from Hamzah Raza on matters associated to US overseas coverage, civil liberties, faith, and every little thing in between. 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here